With the NBA regular season basically done with- and to leave plenty of time for playoff talk, I decided to have the first Sports At Random NBA Regular Season Awards Post (SARNBARSAP- for short). There will be two opinions here- with some banter, then an open debate in the comments section afterwards, probably just between us, but every one is invited.
We are not going to do every category, for several different reasons. No Rookie of the Year because it’s obviously Brandon Roy. No Most Improved because that is a strange category. Who gives out an award that says “You sucked last year”? Only the NBA. Also no Defensive Player of the Year because we didn’t watch every game and neither do the people who actually vote for that award and just give it to Marcus Camby or Jermaine O’Neal because they got a lot of blocks.
So, without further Adu, let’s move on to the Awards (I will be in regular type and My Roommate will be in Italics- because that’s more fruity):
MVP:
3. Chris Bosh - Phoenix not only has Nash, but All-Stars Marion and Amare- who is ridiculous. San Antonio has Manu, Parker, and Duncan. Utah has Okur, Deron, and Boozer. Houston has Yao and T-Mac. Detroit has Chauncey, Rasheed, Tayshaun, Webber, Rip, and McDyess (having a great year off the bench). Chicago has Gordon, Deng, Hinrich (Ben Wallace, too). All of these teams have good to great players (plural, not singular). Toronto has no Center, a good rookie in Bargnani, who got hurt- same with Jorge Garbajosa, and a guy who played in Europe last year as their #2 option (Anthony Parker). Yes, their PG play has been good, with T.J. Ford and an underrated Jose Calderon, but every single NBA GM would take Chauncey, Nash, Deron, and Hinrich over those players combined.
2. Lebron James - see above, but an even stronger argument.
1. Dirk Nowitzki - he does have Josh Howard, but the Mavs have been head-and-shoulders above the rest of the league for much of the season. They have been dominant- and Dirk is the main reason. He’s really changed his game (shoots way less 3’s) and upgraded it (better defense and decision making)- things that a player needs to do for his team to win. He is a nightmare to match-up with and doubling him lets Howard and Terry do what they do. Oh, yeah, and he’s shooting over 50%.
MY ROOMMATE:
Bosh wouldn’t get my vote simply because I think anyone who’s arguing for him is using clauses that historically get disregarded when it comes to MVP voting. You make solid observations….. his less then great teammates, his exceeding expectations this season (as opposed to Lebron underperforming higher individual expecations), his great statistical year… all feathers in his cap.
But then he’s a watered down weaker version of 2006’s logic that Lebron and Kobe shouldn’t have been considered for the most votes for #1 last year. A 50 win team for the Cavs wasn’t good enough even though Lebron was the most impressive player statistically last year when considering the big three (ppg, rpg, apg) leaguewide. The Suns were a better team. Mavs, too. That’s what kept coming up. Nash made the guys around him better they argued. They all had great stat years. The best of their careers. People can convincingly argue Bosh didn’t do that to the Raptors, since they guys who’ve emerged are all rookies or new additions, and having a true floor general (Ford), a potential Coach Of the Year, and some valuable role guys (Bargnani, Jorge, Parker, Dixon) is certainly a factor as to what helped them make such a big leap. Not just a better year from Bosh. They made drastic changes to that rotation on the Raptors. To me, if Lebron was #3 last year, a guy like Bosh might not even make my top 5 using that same logic this year.
I just want consistent reasoning when deciding. Is it individual or team? Or if both matter, which one takes precedent? Is it the five best players in the league, or the five guys who would affect their team the most if they were removed from the roster of their specific team. My feelings: It’s an individual award. It should be the five best guys in the league based first on stats, and then turn to team related stuff (record, guys around him, etc.). It should be that simple. But it isn’t. Because people always make disclaimers and argue the angle that supports who they picked or who they want to win. They’ll turn around and argue the opposite the next year. As far as I’m concerned, the first consideration needs to be paid to what they do individually. And then the team argument/record argument should be turned to when it’s too close to call on statistical domination alone. My ballot:
5. Duncan/McGrady (i think bosh and boozer are right here too, but I turn to the team and I think that’s where I go with McGrady if I had to pick one)
4. Kobe or Lebron (Kobe cause his team is worse then Lebron’s)
3. Kobe or Lebron (I give the nod to LBJ cause of his team)
2. Nash
1. Dirk
COACH OF THE YEAR:
Pat Riley - D.Wade and Shaq were hurt for much of the year and they still win their division going away. Is Jason Kapono really a good player? Chris Quinn even started one game this year for the Heat. So when Wade went down was the season over? Nope. Riles took a bunch of “washed up” Guys (Mourning, Walker, Williams, Jones, Posey… Shaq) and led them to the 4-Seed.
Avery Johnson - His team was amazing. Again. Rivaled the best teams off all-time. Your candidate is your weakest argument. The Heat won a shit (I apologize for his obvious disregard for the children reading) division. You don’t get COY for being the 5th best team in what people call the weak conference. Especially with Shaq/Wade (who still played well over half the year) and a team coming off a title full of “savvy veterans”. Not to mention he didn’t even coach the whole year and they got Jones for nothing mid year. He’s no scrub.
1st Team- All NBA
G: Kobe Bryant
G: Steve Nash
C: Amare Stoudemire
F: Dirk Nowitzki
F: Lebron James
G: Kobe Bryant
G: Steve Nash
C: Yao Ming
F: Dirk Nowitzki
F: Lebron James
Yao didn’t even play 50 games. He’s nowhere to be found on any of my Teams.
But when Yao was healthy, he’s hands down the best in the league at his position. And he doesn’t split time like Amare with Kurt Thomas at the PF spot, or play limited minutes or disappear until he’s needed like Shaq.
2nd Team - All NBA
G: Gilbert Arenas
G: Tracy McGrady
C: Mehmet Okur
F: Tim Duncan
F: Chris Bosh
Curry, as far as I’m concerned, is a much better option for All-NBA then Okur. Okur is a great shooter, but he’s nowhere near the low post threat that Curry is, just as weak a rebounder, and he wouldn’t get nearly as many open looks if Boozer didn’t present a low post alternative. Not to mention Curry’s pretty nimble for being so thick.
I hate the Centers. The league doesn’t play 1-5 anymore. It’s just a bunch of guys out there. Tim Thomas plays Center, Shawn Marion plays Center- lineups change all the time, there always isn’t a 5 in there, maybe not even starting. I think it should be just top 5 players. If they all happen to be PG’s, so be it. But realistically, I think they should just go 2 G’s and 3 F’s/C’s. Defining what is and isn’t a Center is ridiculous- the NBA isn’t like that anymore.
G: Dwyane Wade
G: Tracy McGrady
C: Amare Stoudemire
F: Carlos Boozer
F: Tim Duncan
Boozer, statistically, is debatably better then Bosh on a better team in a tougher conference. Also, this is something that I don’t begrudge, but rather accept as an unfortunate reality. It’s the peaking early vs. peaking late factor. If you’ll remember, early in the season, Boozer was being strongly touted as THE potential MVP. Not to five even, but possibly number one. The Jazz started really strong. They were leading the West. He showed he was healthy and solid, and he got a lot of love from the press. But when your team excels early you set the expectations bar too high. When you excel late, people forgive your apparent under-performance early in the year. Even without Boozer’s individual play falling off, his team’s leveling off made it seem like there was some kind of regression associated with the Jazz. They reality is they could have just played far above expectations at the beginning of the season when everyone was forming their opinions of who should be stacked where (ala Orlando early on). His team’s early success hurts him far more, then the Raptors early season struggles hurt Bosh. It’s the “what have you done for me lately” debate. It shouldn’t factor into an award that takes into account an entire season’s worth of work, but it does. Because the Raptors are pouring it on late, just like Lebron did last season, Bosh is getting his attention now when it matter and guys like Boozer are the victims of delivering back in September and October as opposed to getting their “big” performances out there when ballots are due.
Though your argument has truth to it- as every regular season game counts the same- every minute of every game counts the same, but what makes people hate A-Rod is his HR’s in 8-0 games and fly outs in 4-4 games. Same goes for time of year or time of game. Yes, game 8 counts the same as game 75, but Kobe getting 25 points in the 1st quarter is a lot different than in the 4th quarter. I hope you see my point, despite me mostly agreeing with you.
3rd Team - All NBA
G: Jason Kidd
G: Vince Carter
C: Eddy Curry
F: Kevin Garnett
F: Carlos Boozer
G: Gilbert Arenas
G: Vince Carter
C: Dwight Howard (part of me thinks I should have gone with Shaq)
F: Chris Bosh
F: Kevin Garnett
Dwight Howard disappointed me many times this season. He disappeared for long stretches and even games- though I admit he is better than these other guys (they just had good years). I really wanted to not even include Okur and Curry on this list and add in Shawn Marion and Carmelo Anthony, but, knowing I had to get rid of somebody, I just think Boozer did play great this year and deserves it.
As far as Jason Kidd and Vince Carter go, I really didn’t want two Nets on my 3rd Team, but you can’t look at it that way- you just have to go with who deserves it- and they did over Deron Williams and a barely 50-game playing Dwyane Wade. Yes, he was good this year, but the Heat were barely .500 when he did and I want people who played at least 70% of their team’s games on my top Teams for this season.